In the annals of artistic discourse, the theft or disappearance of a masterpiece transcends the prosaic boundaries of criminality: it constitutes a profound rupture in the fabric of aesthetic, historical, and philosophical understanding. This essay, therefore, endeavours to explore the epistemological, ontological, and semiotic ramifications of one collector’s obsessive attempt to reconstruct the meaning of the famed missing painting within a sequence of seven works by the 19th-century painter Fredéric Tonnerre. Through an interdisciplinary analysis of the collector’s engagement with tableaux vivants and his hermeneutic extrapolations, the discussion investigates the convergence of art, narrative, and the speculative imagination. By treating the collector’s endeavour as both a performative scholarly act and a metaphorical commentary on the limits of interpretative certainty, this essay argues that the absence of the fourth painting reveals the paradoxical nature of absence as both an obstruction and a catalyst for intellectual exploration and what its loss reveals about the interstitial spaces between art, history, and intellectual discovery.
I. The Ontology of the Missing: The Absent Fourth Painting
The absence of the fourth painting in Fredéric Tonnerre’s series of seven canvasses constitutes not merely a physical void but a conceptual absence that destabilises the integrity of the series as a whole. As the collector of Tonnerre’s other paintings recounts, the theft of this pivotal work has left scholars and aesthetes alike grappling with an epistemic lacuna, transforming the series into an enigma defined as much by what is missing as by what remains. Within the collector’s baroque mansion, itself a palimpsest of history and culture, the absence is rendered tangible through the painstaking recreation of the surviving six paintings as tableaux vivants. Using models, props, rigs, and performance lighting to bring the six known canvases to life, this performative act recontextualises the absence by shifting it from a passive lack to an active presence of meaning-making.
The notion of absence as generative echoes Derrida’s hauntological framework, wherein the absent object exerts a spectral presence that both demands and defies closure1. The fourth painting’s disappearance ergo has become the gravitational centre of the collector’s intellectual orbit, compelling him to engage in increasingly elaborate reconstructions to bridge the gap in the narrative. Yet, as this essay will demonstrate, the absence ultimately resists resolution, functioning instead as a perpetual provocation for speculative inquiry.
II. The Tableau Vivant as Methodology: A Phenomenology of Art in Motion
The collector’s decision to recreate the six surviving paintings as tableaux vivants represents a radical methodological innovation, transforming the static medium of painting into a dynamic interplay of corporeality, light, and spatiality. By enlisting models, arranging props, and manipulating lighting, the collector renders each painting as a three-dimensional scene, allowing for an experiential engagement with the very painting and its subject themselves that transcends traditional modes of art historical analysis. Through this process, the collector accesses dimensions of the paintings—literal and figurative—that were previously obscured uncovering secrets that could never be revealed in two-dimensions.
The tableau vivant as a medium recalls Aby Warburg’s Mnemosyne Atlas, wherein images are mobilised to reveal hidden affinities and resonances across temporal and spatial divides2. Similarly, the collector’s enactments transform the paintings into a living archive, enabling him to explore their intertextual relationships through a phenomenological lens. For instance, by physically navigating the tableau of Diana and Actaeon, the collector uncovers nuances of perspective and composition that suggest latent mythological and psychological subtexts. These enactments, however, raise critical questions regarding the fidelity of such recreations and their capacity to “complete” the missing painting’s narrative.
III. Intertextual Narratives and Esoteric Symbolism: The Collector’s Interpretative Web
Throughout his performative investigation, the collector weaves a dense tapestry of narratives and symbolic associations, linking the surviving paintings to mythological, historical, and occult themes. Among these are the tragic tale of Diana and Actaeon, a chess game played by Templar Knights, the decadence of Parisian aristocracy, and a sacrificial ceremony bearing striking resemblances to the martyrdom of St. Sebastian. These thematic threads, while evocative, reveal as much about the collector’s interpretative predilections as they do about the paintings themselves.
The collector’s assertion of a Baphomet cult encoded within the paintings underscores his reliance on esoteric frameworks to construct meaning. This mode of interpretation, though compelling, risks veering into what Hans-Georg Gadamer termed the “hermeneutics of suspicion,” where the interpreter imposes patterns of meaning rather than uncovering them3. It is key therefore that we highlight the tension between interpretative ambition and the limitations imposed by incomplete evidence. Ultimately, the collector’s speculative narratives, while intricate, remain unresolved, illustrating the inherent instability of meaning in the absence of definitive context.
V. The Disintegration of the Tableau: The Aesthetic of Collapse
As the collector progresses through his investigation, the tableaux vivants—initially pristine in their execution—begin to falter under the strain of their artificiality. Actors struggle to maintain their poses, blinking and shifting as the collector’s demands grow increasingly exacting. This gradual unravelling symbolises the limits of artifice as a means of capturing the ineffable qualities of the lost painting. The tableaux, once a source of insight, devolves into a disarray that mirrors the collector’s own epistemic frustrations.
This aesthetic of collapse echoes the modernist critique of representation articulated by Theodor Adorno, who argued that the attempt to impose totality upon fragmented realities ultimately reveals the insufficiency of representation itself4. The disintegration of the tableaux vivants thus functions as both a literal breakdown and a metaphorical commentary on the futility of reconstructing the missing painting’s meaning through purely performative means. It is in this moment of collapse that the collector’s quest reaches its aporia—a point at which further inquiry is rendered impossible by the limitations of the medium and the absence it seeks to resolve.
VI. The Collector’s Departure: Absence as Infinite Regress
Ultimately a failure in concept and execution, it is said that the collector abandoned his baroque mansion and collection itself at the terminus of his inquiry. First-hand accounts reveal that as he walked through his gallery one final time, passing the remnants of the tableaux vivants who after days of static recreation were now sprawled across the space in an exhausted and chaotic tableau of their own unintended creation, the relationship between the paintings and himself had been irrevocably altered. By abandoning his investigation and the very things he had spent his life acquiring, it was a tacit acknowledgment of the futility of his quest. Yet, if we are to linger upon the dishevelled tableaux vivants, we are perhaps glimpsing the ultimate meaning of the seven paintings after all.
Taking the above into consideration then, the collector’s exit does not signify failure but rather the realisation that the search for meaning in art is inherently unending. This resonates with the philosophy of Jean-Luc Nancy, who posited that meaning is always “in excess,” I.E. existing beyond the confines of definitive interpretation5. The absence of the fourth painting thus becomes a site of infinite regress, where every attempt to uncover its truth generates new questions and interpretations rather than the definitive answer sought.
VII. Absence as Catalyst
The attempt to uncover the content of the missing fourth painting by restaging the six remaining offers a profound meditation on the interplay between absence, art, and interpretation. Through the collector’s obsessive reconstruction of Fredéric Tonnerre’s series, the case reveals the paradoxical nature of absence as both an impediment to and a catalyst for intellectual engagement. The tableaux vivants, while innovative, ultimately underscore the limitations of performative methodologies in addressing the epistemological gaps left by loss. Similarly, the collector’s intertextual narratives, though evocative, highlight the subjective dimensions of interpretation and the impossibility of definitive closure.
As this essay has demonstrated, the absence of the fourth painting transcends its physical loss, emerging as a conceptual presence that reshapes the narrative context of the six remaining paintings and the interpretative possibilities of the series. The collector’s journey, while certainly marked by unique moments of insight, ultimately culminates in the recognition that art resists meaning and resolution even as it compels further inquiry. In this sense, Tonnerre’s missing fourth painting is not merely a case study in art historical investigation but a reflection on the nature of interpretation itself—an intellectual journey where absence, rather than definitive meaning, serves as its perpetual source. Thus, the fourth painting is nothing more than a catalyst for endless discovery.
[1] Derrida, J. (1982). Spectres de l’absence: Art, Loss, and the Hauntological Turn. Paris: Éditions du Seuil.
[2] Warburg, A. (1929). Mnemosyne Atlas: Iconology and the Memory of Images. Leipzig: De Gruyter.
[3] Gadamer, H.-G. (1960). Wahrheit und Methode: Grundzüge einer philosophischen Hermeneutik. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.
[4] Adorno, T. W. (1966). Negative Dialectics and the Aesthetics of Collapse. Frankfurt am Main: Suhrkamp Verlag.
[5] Nancy, J.-L. (1993). Le sens du monde: Fragmentations de la signification dans l’art. Paris: Galilée.
Sokal Nouveau 